| 1st Period Summary |
| Time left | Team | Scoring Detail |
| 8:09 | NY Islanders | NY Islanders Goal - Michael Grabner (10), from Colin McDonald and Andrew MacDonald at 11:51. |
| Time | Team | Penalty Detail |
| No Penalties |
| |
| 2nd Period Summary |
| Time left | Team | Scoring Detail |
| No Scoring |
| No Penalties |
| Time | Team | Penalty Detail |
| 11:07 | NY Islanders | Casey Cizikas - 2 minutes for holding |
| 11:07 | NY Rangers | Stu Bickel - 2 minutes for unsportsmanlike conduct |
| 11:07 | NY Islanders | Joe Finley - 2 minutes for unsportsmanlike conduct |
| 16:05 | NY Islanders | Kyle Okposo - 2 minutes for tripping |
| |
| 3rd Period Summary |
| Time left | Team | Scoring Detail |
| 5:23 | NY Rangers | NY Rangers Goal - Rick Nash (8), from Derek Stepan and Carl Hagelin at 14:37. |
| Time | Team | Penalty Detail |
| No Penalties |
| |
| Overtime Summary |
| Time left | Team | Scoring Detail |
| 4:18 | NY Rangers | NY Rangers Power-Play Goal - Marian Gaborik (8), from Rick Nash and Derek Stepan at :42. |
| No Penalties |
| Time | Team | Penalty Detail |
| :21 | NY Islanders | Michael Grabner - 2 minutes for hooking |
| :42 | NY Islanders | Kyle Okposo - 10 minutes for misconduct (10 min) |
| :42 | NY Islanders | Bench - 0 minutes for game misconduct - team staff served by Kevin Poulin |